Skip to content
guideNovember 21, 2026 · 9 min read

Crypto Earn programmes on a licensed exchange: structures, yield sources and what regulators have said

How a crypto Earn programme works on an exchange: flexible and fixed terms, where the yield comes from, what regulators have said and what the software must do.

BitPolaris Engineering

A crypto Earn programme lets an exchange customer commit a balance for a flexible or fixed term and receive a stated rate on it. On screen it is a rate, a term and a button. Behind the screen the operator has to answer one question before any other: where does the yield come from? Staking, lending and the operator’s own revenue are three different activities. Regulators treat them differently, and in some markets a retail customer cannot be offered one of them at all.

This article covers how Earn programmes are structured, the three yield sources, what regulators in the EU, the UK, the US, Hong Kong, Dubai and Singapore have published, what the software has to do, and a checklist before launch. Every regulatory source was read on 21 November 2026. It is a technical reading of the rules, not legal advice; counsel should confirm what your licence and local law allow. We sell exchange software with an Earn module, so we describe it near the end and say what it does not cover.

How is a crypto Earn programme structured?

Three product shapes cover most of what exchanges offer. The terms in the table are examples, not a standard.

Flexible Fixed term (locked) Dual-asset
Commitment None; the customer redeems at any time A set term, for example 30 or 90 days Until a set expiry
Rate Variable; the operator can change it Fixed when the customer subscribes Fixed, usually higher than on the plain products
What comes back The same asset plus the accrued reward The same asset plus the reward at maturity One of two assets, depending on the price at expiry
Operator’s main risk Redemptions arriving faster than deployed assets can be recalled Early-exit requests; a rate set too high for the term Pricing and hedging the embedded option

A flexible product looks like a savings balance, and that resemblance is the first legal question. A fixed term lets the treasury match what it owes to what it has deployed, for example to a staking exit period. A dual-asset product is a different instrument: the customer has in effect sold an option, so expect counsel to analyse it under derivatives or structured-product rules, not as a reward programme.

Every product also needs a cap per customer, a cap for the whole programme, an eligibility rule and an exit rule. Those belong in the product definition, not on the marketing page.

Where does the yield come from?

  • Staking. The operator stakes customers’ proof-of-stake assets, itself or through a validator operator, receives protocol rewards and passes them on less a fee. The protocol sets the reward, so the rate varies. The risks are slashing, exit delays and validator downtime.
  • Lending. The operator takes customers’ assets and lends them on: to margin traders on its own venue, to institutional borrowers or into lending protocols. The yield is interest, and the risks are borrower default and a collateral shortfall. In its September 2026 response to the Commission’s MiCA review, ESMA called such programmes “effectively black boxes for clients”, who often do not know the borrowers, the collateral or the gross yield.
  • Operator-funded rewards. The operator pays the rate from its own revenue, such as trading fees or a marketing budget, and does not deploy the customer’s balance. This is a promotion with a cost line. It carries the least operational risk, but it is not outside regulation by default: a return tied to how long a balance is held can count as interest, and a fixed return on balances the operator can use raises deposit-taking questions under national banking law.

The source decides the treatment because each one does something different with client assets. Staked assets remain client assets under custody rules. Lent assets leave safeguarding: the FCA’s final rules describe cryptoasset lending as a disposal in which the assets “become the property of the recipient”, and ESMA says MiCA safeguarding “will also not apply to assets used in lending programmes”. Operator-funded rewards move no client assets but are still a payment for holding.

The combination to avoid is a screen that describes one source while the treasury uses another. Consent, disclosure and accounting all follow the real source. How a crypto exchange makes money treats Earn as a revenue line; the next section shows how narrow that line is in some markets.

What have regulators actually said about Earn, staking and lending?

None of these texts says Earn is permitted as a product. Each addresses an activity, a client type and conditions. The ESMA and Commission answers are supervisory guidance, not legislation. Numbers in brackets refer to the Sources list.

Jurisdiction Staking client assets Lending client assets
EU MiCA has no staking provisions. The Commission’s answer of 20 June 2024: staking for clients is ancillary to custody and needs the custody authorisation of Article 75; losses from staking count as attributable to the provider; explicit consent is needed when staking is combined with other services [2]. ESMA, 9 July 2025: no staking of client assets for the provider’s own account, even with consent [3] Recital 94: MiCA “should not address” lending and borrowing, so national law applies [1]. ESMA, 18 June 2026: providers can offer lending, but need “prior express and specific consent” that is not buried in general terms; revenue should go to the client apart from a fair fee; some arrangements could be alternative investment funds [4]
UK FCA PS26/11, in force 25 October 2027. For retail clients: information on the service and risks such as slashing, key terms with express prior consent, consent only for named cryptoassets (no blanket consent), and a notice at least every 12 months [7][8] Same policy statement, retail clients: information before the service, express prior consent each time, an appropriateness test, extra record-keeping, and no proprietary tokens [8]
US SEC staff statement, 29 May 2025: certain protocol staking, including custodial, is not a securities offering in the staff’s view if the custodian does not decide “whether, when, or how much” to stake and does not guarantee or fix rewards. It has “no legal force or effect” [11]. Before it, Kraken paid $30 million in February 2023 and ended its staking programme, without admitting or denying the allegations [10] BlockFi agreed in February 2022 to pay $100 million ($50 million to the SEC, $50 million to 32 states) over interest accounts the SEC found were unregistered securities [9]. This is enforcement history, not a rulebook
Hong Kong VATP Guidelines 7.26(b) bar arrangements that use client assets “with the effect of generating returns” [13]. The SFC circular of 7 April 2025 opens staking with prior written approval and licence conditions: the platform keeps control of every means of withdrawal and discloses fees, lock-ups, the unstaking process and risks [14] We found no SFC circular that opens lending of client assets for returns; 7.26(b) stands in the Guidelines as downloaded on 21 November 2026
Dubai (VARA) Staking from Custody only if “explicitly authorised” and written into the licence; never on an opt-out basis; one client’s assets may not be pooled with another’s [15] Lending and Borrowing Services is a licensed activity with its own rulebook: the rate disclosed as an annual percentage yield, fixed or variable, estimate or not, accrual frequency, simple or compound; monthly statements; a published asset and liability report every three months; withdrawable assets sent within 24 hours [16]
Singapore MAS said on 3 July 2023 it would restrict providers from facilitating staking of retail customers’ tokens; institutional and accredited investors are outside the restriction [17] The same statement covers lending [17]

Stablecoins need a separate check. MiCA Articles 40 and 50 say issuers and crypto-asset service providers “shall not grant interest” on asset-referenced and e-money tokens, and treat “any remuneration or any other benefit related to the length of time” the token is held as interest, including benefits paid by third parties [1]. In our reading that reaches an operator-funded reward on a euro or dollar e-money token balance; counsel should confirm. In the US, section 4(a)(11) of the GENIUS Act bars payment stablecoin issuers from paying holders interest or yield [12]; how that applies to an exchange’s own programme is a question for US counsel.

Five patterns repeat across these texts:

  1. Consent is specific and comes first. Not a line in the terms of business, and not opt-out.
  2. The rate mechanics are disclosed: fixed or variable, estimated or not, when it accrues, what fees come out.
  3. Retail and professional clients are treated differently.
  4. Approval comes before launch where the licence lists services. New York adds a change-control rule that our BitLicense guide covers.
  5. The regulated badge must not cover the unregulated product. ESMA’s July 2025 statement warns of a “halo effect” when a provider offers regulated and unregulated services on the same platform [5].

In the EU the margin model is narrower than many business plans assume: ESMA’s answer leaves the operator a fee, not the spread [4]. ESMA has also asked the Commission for targeted staking and lending requirements in the MiCA review [6]. That is a proposal, not law. Our MiCA application guide covers the custody rules staking falls under.

What does the software have to do?

Function What it must do Why
Product definition Asset, term, fixed or variable rate, minimum, caps per customer and per programme, exit rule Caps bound the liability before marketing does
Eligibility Open a product by country of residence, verification level and client category Retail restrictions differ by market
Disclosure and consent Show product-specific terms before opt-in; record the text version, time and account ESMA, the FCA and VARA all ask for prior, specific consent
Accrual ledger Accrue per position on a schedule, as ledger entries; date every rate change Statements and disputes are settled from this record
Treasury Pay rewards from a dedicated account kept apart from customer custody; record each movement A reward paid out of customer funds creates a shortfall
Stop switch Close new subscriptions per product or country at once; define what happens to open positions A rule change or a counterparty failure will not wait for a release
Statements and reports Per customer: positions, rewards, fees. For the operator: liabilities by product and maturity VARA asks for monthly statements; the FCA for a notice every 12 months
Audit trail Who created or changed a product, rate or cap, and when The first thing a reviewer asks; see our admin panel guide

Ask any vendor, us included, to show each row on a running system.

What BitPolaris Earn covers

Earn is an optional module of our Exchange and Wallet blocks and runs on the same ledger, identity and custody. The product pages list:

  • flexible and fixed-term reward programmes with operator-set terms and caps, and a dual-asset product type;
  • a term picker in the mobile app, with the APR shown per term;
  • daily accrual;
  • an Earn console with products, positions and the accrual log;
  • an Earn treasury with its own accounts, kept apart from customer custody, with its movements recorded under internal transfers;
  • programmes switched on from the admin, product by product, only where your licence allows.

The module costs €85 a month on the cloud option or €1,400 one-time on a self-hosted or source-code licence, for the Exchange and for the Wallet (pricing).

The pages do not list validator operation, a lending desk or collateral management. How the treasury earns what it pays out is your decision, under your licence. If your regulator needs something the list does not name, such as a consent record tied to a disclosure version or a statement in a set format, scope it before you sign; custom development is quoted per project. Installing the module does not make a programme lawful anywhere.

Which structure, which yield source, and what to check with counsel

Product Yield source What happens to the customer’s assets Check with counsel
Flexible or fixed Staking Staked on the customer’s behalf; remain client assets Is staking tied to a custody permission or a separate approval? Who bears slashing? Is each protocol approved?
Flexible or fixed Lending Leave safeguarding; the customer holds a claim Is lending licensed here, and open to retail? Securities or fund analysis? Collateral, consent wording, fee or spread?
Flexible or fixed Operator-funded Stay in custody, untouched Is the reward interest under stablecoin rules? Deposit-taking, promotion and incentive rules?
Dual-asset Option premium Converted at expiry on set terms Derivative or structured product? Which client categories?

What should an operator do before launch?

  1. Write down the yield source for each product and name the counterparty, validator or budget behind it.
  2. Get counsel’s written view per country and client category, and turn it into eligibility rules, not a paragraph in the terms.
  3. Check the licence scope. Where staking or lending needs approval or a named activity, apply before you build the marketing.
  4. Draft product-specific disclosures and a consent step separate from the general terms.
  5. Size the caps and the treasury. For flexible products, model redemptions against the time it takes to recall deployed assets.
  6. Test on staging: a subscription, a rate change, an early exit and a maturity, then reconcile the accrual ledger against the treasury account.
  7. Rehearse the stop switch and a wind-down of open positions.
  8. Match the app store declaration. If Earn is not declared, the binary should not contain it; our wallet app guide explains how we compile it out.

Crypto Earn programme FAQ

What is a crypto Earn programme?

A product in which an exchange or wallet customer commits a balance for a flexible or fixed term and receives a stated rate. The rate is funded by staking rewards, by interest from lending the assets or by the operator’s own revenue. Which of the three it is decides the risks the customer carries and the rules the operator must follow.

It depends on the yield source, the client type and the country, and none of the regulators we read gives a blanket yes. The EU ties staking to custody authorisation and attaches conditions to lending; the UK’s retail rules apply from 25 October 2027; Hong Kong and Dubai require specific approval for staking; MAS said it would restrict both for retail customers. Treat each product in each market as its own legal question.

What is the difference between staking and lending in an Earn product?

In staking, the assets support a proof-of-stake network and the reward comes from the protocol; the main risks are slashing and exit delays. In lending, the assets pass to a borrower and the reward is interest; the main risks are default and a collateral shortfall. Regulators separate the two: the FCA noted that retail clients may “conflate” them.

Can an exchange pay interest on stablecoins in the EU?

MiCA Articles 40 and 50 bar crypto-asset service providers from granting interest when providing services related to asset-referenced and e-money tokens, and define interest widely enough to include benefits tied to holding time and paid by third parties. Any reward on such tokens needs counsel’s review before launch.

Does Earn software make a programme compliant?

No. Software enforces the terms, caps, eligibility and consent you configure and keeps the accrual record. The licence, the legal analysis, the disclosures and the treasury that funds the rate are the operator’s.

BitPolaris Exchange has an optional Earn module: flexible and fixed-term reward programmes with operator-set terms and caps, daily accrual and an Earn console, switched on only where your licence allows. Prices are public.

See the Exchange block · Build an estimate

Sources

All read on 21 November 2026.

  1. Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 (MiCA), Recital 94 and Articles 40, 50, 66, 70 and 75, EUR-Lex
  2. European Commission answer published by ESMA, ESMA_QA_2067, Treatment of staking services in MiCA, 20 June 2024
  3. ESMA, ESMA_QA_2607, Staking on own account, 9 July 2025
  4. ESMA, ESMA_QA_2883, Crypto-asset lending services under MiCA, 18 June 2026
  5. ESMA, Avoiding misperceptions: guidance for crypto-asset service providers offering unregulated services, ESMA35-1872330276-2329, 11 July 2025
  6. ESMA, Response to the EC consultation on the review of MiCA, ESMA75-113276571-1721, 30 September 2026 (sections 7.1 and 7.2)
  7. FCA, Overview of our cryptoassets regime policy statements, 30 June 2026
  8. FCA, PS26/11, Regulated cryptoasset activities, 30 June 2026 (chapters 6 and 8)
  9. SEC, BlockFi agrees to pay $100 million in penalties and pursue registration of its crypto lending product, 14 February 2022
  10. SEC, Kraken to discontinue unregistered offer and sale of crypto asset staking-as-a-service program, 9 February 2023
  11. SEC Division of Corporation Finance, Statement on certain protocol staking activities, 29 May 2025
  12. GENIUS Act, Public Law 119-27, section 4(a)(11), govinfo, 18 July 2025
  13. SFC, Guidelines for Virtual Asset Trading Platform Operators, June 2023 (paragraph 7.26)
  14. SFC, Circular on staking services provided by virtual asset trading platforms, 7 April 2025
  15. VARA, Custody Services Rulebook, Part IV, Staking from Custody Services Rules (rulebook effective from 19 June 2025)
  16. VARA, Lending and Borrowing Services Rulebook (effective from 19 June 2025)
  17. MAS, MAS publishes investor protection measures for digital payment token services, 3 July 2023

Exchange software already in production

Spot trading, liquidity mirroring and the operations console. Cloud from €1,600/month, self-hosted from €24,500 one-time.